mcfarland minutes

EPISODE

33

Why General Marketing Advice Doesn't Always Work

EPISODE LINKS.

SHOW NOTES.

In this episode of McFarland Minutes, the team discusses why general marketing advice often falls short and how to tailor strategies specific to your business needs and audience. The conversation highlights the importance of individualized marketing tactics, recognizing unique audience behaviors, and the limitations of following trends and general recommendations blindly. Personal anecdotes and examples, such as the use of storytelling in rodeo marketing and the effectiveness of lunch and learns, illustrate the value of personalized marketing strategies over generic advice.

00:00 Introduction to McFarland Minutes
00:03 The Problem with General Marketing Advice
00:28 Personal Preferences in Marketing Strategies
01:35 Importance of Unique Marketing Tactics
03:29 Showcasing Personal Achievements
06:34 The Role of Theory in Marketing
08:03 Understanding Audience Behavior
12:07 Effective Marketing Strategies
12:43 Entertaining and Relatable Content
15:26 Questioning General Marketing Advice
17:45 Targeting Local Audiences with Streaming Ads
18:25 The Evolution of Music Streaming Services
19:43 The Importance of Marketing Strategy
22:16 Building Brand Community and Engagement
23:54 The Debate on Paid Ads and Trends
25:40 Evaluating Social Media Trends for Business
31:39 General Advice and Final Thoughts

ABOUT THIS EPISODE.

Marketing is often accompanied by an endless stream of advice, recommendations, and strategies from social media, teachers, or self-proclaimed experts. However, not everything labeled as valuable marketing guidance applies to every business. In this post, we explore why general marketing advice doesn’t always work and how to create strategies that are effective for your specific needs.

Many businesses are bombarded with broad marketing suggestions such as maintaining a social media presence, sending emails, or running ad campaigns. While these are foundational marketing tools, they can also feel generic. The problem arises when little consideration is given to the unique aspects of a business or its audience.

The distinction between general advice and a tailored strategy is critical. Some baseline recommendations, like having a website, are broadly useful, but the heart of an effective marketing plan lies in customization. Understanding your audience is essential. The uses and gratifications theory suggests that audiences actively seek media that fulfills particular needs. Your marketing should aim to meet these needs, whether they are entertainment, information, or connection.

Crafting a strategy means looking beyond standard recommendations and focusing on what sets your business apart. What differentiates you from competitors? How can you use these strengths to build a community around your brand? These questions are central to developing an effective plan. Targeting your marketing on platforms and channels that your audience actually uses is more meaningful than spreading efforts thin across every possible medium. Analyzing your market and choosing where to focus allows your strategy to resonate more effectively.

Personalized marketing efforts can include creating storytelling content for specific industries, like rodeo entertainment, or incorporating insider jokes, such as references that only a community would understand. These approaches build memorable connections. Similarly, advertising choices should reflect the audience’s context. A niche manufacturer may gain more from attending specialized trade shows than running broad streaming ads, while a local restaurant hosting live music could benefit from geo-targeted ads that reach customers with a shared interest in music.

Not every trend is right for every business. It is important to evaluate whether following a trending topic or using trending audio aligns with your values and audience. If a trend increases engagement but does not lead to conversions, it may not be serving your bottom line.

General advice can be a helpful starting point, but a one-size-fits-all approach rarely captures the nuances of a brand or its audience. By crafting strategies attuned to the behaviors, desires, and needs of your audience, you can create a marketing plan that resonates and performs. Tailoring advice and trends to fit your unique business ensures that your marketing is both effective and authentic.

ABOUT YOUR HOSTS.

NATALIE MCFARLAND

Headshot image of Natalie McFarland wearing a black suit, red hat, and long blonde hair in front.

PRESIDENT, FOUNDER

MCFARLAND PRODUCTIONS

After freelancing her way through college, Natalie established McFarland Productions in 2014, which has continued to grow rapidly over the last few years. Her passion and focus have always remained the same; capturing, understanding, preserving and promoting Ranching, Farming, Western Lifestyle and AgriBusiness. She has always had a love for the western culture and even at a young age it was unmistakably clear she would someday find a career serving the industry.

Natalie grew up on a small ranch, rodeoed, showed horses in a variety of disciplines, showed livestock, and participated in 4H and Oregon High School Equestrian Teams. She has trained herding dogs and started colts, worked with sheep and cattle and has had the experience of racing to finish up a hayfield before a rainstorm hit. She understands the joys, sorrows, wins, losses and hard work of ranchers and farmers. That’s why McFarland Productions can produce authentic marketing campaigns for the businesses, organizations, events, and brands of the western and agriculture industry – it’s who she is.

With a passion for building community surrounding brands, Natalie focuses on building real connections between companies/brands and the people that make up their community. Telling the stories of your customers and making them apart of the brand’s story is her main focus. Creating real, human, meaningful connections and strengthening community within the western and agriculture industry through strategic marketing services.

SCOUT FOSTER

Marketing manager Scout in front of a horse statue wearing a red shirt, black pants, and jean jacket. She has her long brown hair down in front of her shoulders.

DIRECTOR OF STRATEGIC STORYTELLING

MCFARLAND PRODUCTIONS

Scout’s faithfulness to the agriculture and western sports industry is rooted in tradition. Growing up in Central Florida, she stood by her family as they supported different sectors of the industry, including raising beef cattle, bucking bulls for local rodeos, and spending weekends with her grandparents who lived on Disney’s Wilderness Preserve.

Moving away from The Mouse, Scout graduated Magna Cum Laude from the Nation’s top agricultural communications college at Texas Tech University in 2022.
Now residing in Crockett, she and her husband, Lane, keep busy raising beef cattle and bucking bulls with her family. Scout also loves gardening, raising chickens, reading, and her two dogs: Rue and Dill.

Sign Up to Receive Updates About McFarland Minutes!


BUILD COMMUNITY WITH US.
Subscribe to our newsletter for McFPro Staff updates, staying up to date with our podcast, McFarland Minutes, and what is new at Off Your Rocker Films.